The Shareholder Forum

for

Telephone and Data Systems, Inc.

Forum Home Page

TDS Home Page

TDS Reference

 

 

July 6, 2009 Forum Report:

Management Resistance to Investor Information Requirements

 

 

Forum Report: TDS

Management Resistance to Investor Information Requirements

TDS management delivered an official response last week to the Forum's June 24, 2009 information request, stating that they did not intend to provide any information because the request did not comply with unspecified statutory requirements.  Following is the entire text of management's letter:[1]

Telephone and Data Systems, Inc. has received a letter dated June 24, 2009 from you, purporting to make a demand on the Company pursuant to Section 220 of the Delaware General Corporation Law on behalf of Leonard Rosenthal. We do not believe that the demand complies with the statute's requirements, including, without limitation, the requirements as to the form and manner of making a demand and for a proper purpose. Accordingly, the Company declines to permit the requested inspection.

The company’s representative was immediately asked to provide some indication of the particular statutory requirements that needed to be addressed, but there has been no response.[2]  I have therefore sent the company a revised demand letter, copied below.  As stated in that letter, any genuine management questions about statutory requirements should be satisfied by the addition of issues numbered “2,” “3” and “4” concerning the conventionally respected interests of shareholders relating to officer and director fiduciary duties.

Today’s letter repeats the suggestion that management simply present its own report of the relevant information.  Their responses so far, though, including the dismissal of shareholder questions at the annual meeting as well as last week's unexplained refusal to satisfy a formal demand for the information, suggest that we should be prepared for a more burdensome process.  Under these circumstances, I will welcome your suggestions to guide both the prioritizing of investor interests and the efficiency of our efforts to obtain the information you need for your decisions.

GL – July 6, 2009

 

Gary Lutin

Lutin & Company

575 Madison Avenue, 10th Floor

New York, New York 10022

Tel: 212-605-0335

Email: gl@shareholderforum.com


 

[1] For a copy of the letter, delivered by email at 5:49PM on the final day of the period allowed by statute, see the July 1, 2009 letter of Kevin C. Gallagher, Vice President and Corporate Secretary of Telephone and Data Systems, Inc. (1 page, 33 KB, in PDF format).

 


 

The Shareholder Forum, Inc.

 

c/o Lutin & Company

575 Madison Avenue – 10th Floor, New York, New York  10022

Telephone: (212) 605-0335

 

   

July 6, 2009

By email

 

Mr. LeRoy T. Carlson, Jr.

Telephone and Data Systems, Inc.

30 North LaSalle Street
Suite 4000
Chicago, Illinois 60602

 

Re:       Demand for records

Dear Mr. Carlson:

Since Mr. Gallagher has not explained any basis for his July 1, 2009 letter’s stated belief that my June 24, 2009 letter did not comply with statutory requirements for shareholder access to information, I will revise the form of the demand with added issues and purposes that are conventionally respected.

Continuing to act as a shareholder Delegate according to the powers of attorney and evidence of stock ownership accompanying the attached June 24, 2009 letter, and having no notice or knowledge that those powers have been revoked, I now demand pursuant to Section 220 of the Delaware General Corporation Law that you produce for inspection and copying all books and records of Telephone Data and Systems, Inc. (“TDA” or the “Company”), relating to board or individual director consideration of the following matters, including but not limited to board minutes, briefings, exhibits, management or consultant reports, other professional analyses or recommendations, and communications with or among directors:

(1) the questions presented to directors in a report on May 15, 2009 and at the Company’s annual meeting of shareholders on May 21, 2009, as previously demanded in the June 24, 2009 letter which is attached for reference;

(2) what is described on page 89 of the Company’s most recent proxy statement as “a written, all cash, significant premium bid for TDS from a well-resourced strategic acquirer” in 2008;

(3) the failure of a Company officer and director to inform the board of the proposed transaction in 2008, as also reported on page 89 of the most recent proxy statement; and

(4) the adequacy of internal controls for related party transactions, generally, and specifically concerning the affiliated United States Cellular Corporation and Sidley Austin LLP.

            The purposes of this revised demand are to obtain information relevant to shareholder decisions about both investment commitments and voting matters, including evaluations of (a) management policies, (b) the performance of the Company's directors, individually and collectively, (c) the views of each director regarding his or her responsibilities to consider shareholder interests, and (d) the possible need for actions to protect investor rights or interests.

Any confidential material should be identified, as indicated in my initial June 24 demand letter, so that appropriate arrangements can be made for its review.  All of my statements in the June 24 letter concerning confidentiality provisions and the reporting of information are applicable to this revised demand.

            If you believe that this demand fails to comply with any requirements of Section 220, or of any other condition for obtaining information relevant to investor interests, I must ask that you state your position with sufficient particularity for me to understand it.  I will in any event expect your response within five business days, as required by statute, and continue to encourage your suggestions for providing the information as efficiently as possible.

Sincerely yours,

 

/s

 

Gary Lutin,

            as Delegate

 

Attachment

 

cc:        Mr. Kevin C. Gallagher

            

 

 

www.ShareholderForum.com

 

 

 

This Forum program is open to all shareholders of Telephone and Data Systems, Inc. (NYSE: TDS), and its controlled subsidiary, United States Cellular Corporation (NYSE: USM), and to any fiduciaries or professionals concerned with their investment decisions. Participation is free of charge, according to the Forum's standard Conditions of Participation.

The purpose of the Forum is to provide shareholders with access to information and a free exchange of views relating to their consideration of issues described in the Forum Summary. As stated in the Conditions, all Forum participants are expected to make independent use of information obtained through the Forum, subject to the privacy rights of other participants. Forum polices are intended to support anonymous communication, and provide that participants will not be identified or quoted without their explicit permission.

The initiation of this program was supported by Southeastern Asset Management, Inc., which as manager of the Longleaf Partners Funds and other client funds is the largest TDS shareholder with common and special common stock aggregating more than 15% of the total of all classes outstanding. TDS has been invited to assume corporate responsibility for the costs of addressing issues of apparent significance to a broad range of its investors, according to the Forum's Conditions, and other participants may be invited to contribute support to the continuing program pending the company's acceptance of responsibility.

Inquiries and requests to be included in the Forum's distribution list may be addressed to tds@shareholderforum.com.

The information provided to Forum participants is intended for their private reference, and permission has not been granted for the republishing of any copyrighted material. The material presented on this web site is the responsibility of Gary Lutin, as chairman of the Shareholder Forum.