Shareholder Forum for Options Policies

Forum Home Page

Options Policies Home Page

Program Reference

 

Financial Times, April 1, 2007 article and document reference

 

 
SEC chief sees funny side of pay and perks

By Jeremy Grant in Washington

Published: April 1 2007 21:12 | Last updated: April 1 2007 21:12

 

With its army of lawyers and accountants, the US Securities and Exchange Commission is not renowned as one of the world’s major joke factories. But Christopher Cox, its chairman, seems determined to imbue it with an impish sense of humour.

The chairman of the US markets watchdog – a former congressman with a history of April Fool pranks – approved the issuing of a spoof press release supposedly announcing “plans” to require publicly-listed companies to reveal the pay and perks of the “top 100 people who make more than the CEO”.

In the real world, the SEC already has proposed a rule requiring disclosure for a company’s three highest paid people.

Known as the “Katie Couric provision”, after the US news anchor, its aim is to get companies to show how much they are paying celebrities and sports stars to sit on their boards.

But in the spoof release, issued at Mr Cox’s initiative, the SEC quoted “April Fuhrst”, an SEC spokeswoman, promising the changes would “reveal a treasure trove of titillating information”.

“From readers of People Magazine to those who are now assembling their fantasy baseball league rosters, regular Americans will appreciate the ready access they’ll have to this new data,” she is quoted as saying.

“It will show compensation levels not only for Wall Street traders but also movie stars, professional athletes and network anchors.”

An SEC economist billed as “Anita Moore-Profit” said the SEC had settled on the 100 figure for convenience. “It’s a round number. Something people can remember.”

April Fool jokes are unheard of at the SEC. It was founded in the wake of the Wall Street crash of 1929 – hardly a laughing matter.

But Mr Cox has recently tried to inject levity into the agency’s often leaden proceedings, building on his history as a congressional prankster.

Shortly after singer Janet Jackson’s infamous “wardrobe malfunction” at the Super Bowl, Mr Cox – then a Republican lawmaker from California – issued a “press release” announcing that her brother Michael Jackson had agreed on a bill to “curb indecency on the public airwaves”.

Mr Cox last month held a press briefing to unveil a sting on companies punting penny stocks through spam emails, dubbed “Operation Spamalot”.

How the attempt at humour will go down among the SEC’s hard-boiled enforcement lawyers remains to be seen. But it can only help the SEC as its seeks to shake off an image abroad as among the most aloof regulators.

The test may come next week in Mumbai, where the world’s markets regulators will gather for their annual meeting.

 

Published: April 1 2007 21:02 | Last updated: April 1 2007 21:02

 

The Securities and Exchange Commission sent this press release to journalists on Sunday, April 1 – April Fools’ Day.

Qouting a spokeswoman by the name of April Fuhrst, it purports to announce plans to force public companies to reveal the pay and perks of the “top 100 people who make more than the CEO”.

The full, unedited text of the spoof release follows below.

 

EMBARGOED UNTIL RELEASED BY SOURCE 2007-1234

SEC TO PROPOSE REVISED ’KATIE COURIC’ RULE

Washington, DC, April 1 2007 - The Securities and Exchange Commission today announced plans to expand disclosure of how public companies compensate their highest-paid talent. Under the proposed new rules, disclosure will now extend to the top 100 people who make more than the CEO.

The Commission’s pending proposal to extend pay reporting to non-executive officers -- the so-called ”Katie Couric rule” -- had been limited to the top three people who make more than the CEO.

”The proposed changes will reveal a treasure trove of titillating information,” said SEC spokeswoman April Fuhrst. ”From readers of People Magazine to those who are now assembling their fantasy baseball league rosters, regular Americans will appreciate the ready access they’ll have to this new data. It will show compensation levels not only for Wall Street traders but also movie stars, professional athletes, and network anchors. Corporate payments to college athletes will be specifically included, so everyone will have better luck next year when they fill out their college basketball brackets.”

The Commission arrived at 100 as the appropriate number after extensive economic analysis. ”We received bunches of comments from all sorts of people who didn’t want their pay disclosed,” said the SEC’s Deputy Chief Economist, Anita Moore-Profit, ”so we knew there must be lots of them out there. We basically settled on 100 for convenience. It’s a round number. Something people can remember.” Simultaneously with the issuance of its economic analysis, the Commission took the unusual step of suing itself - both to save time, and to be assured of being on the winning side when the court rules.

The proposal to require pay disclosures for more people also includes provisions for real-time disclosure, which build upon the SEC’s commitment to interactive data.

”Since the payroll function in virtually every public company is now electronic,” said Edgar Philing, the SEC’s Assistant Chief Information Officer, ”there is no reason the SEC can’t receive the information about a bank deposit or withdrawal at the same time it’s made. So when the CEO’s paycheck is automatically deposited, ordinary investors could get an RSS feed on their laptops or handhelds alerting them to the news. The same would be true for the reporting of perquisites. Each use of an executive’s credit card would show up on EDGAR at the same instant.”

Real-time data input, in turn, would open up the possibility of instant comparisons among companies, across industries, and between people within a given company. ”We could immediately see which is the most popular car to drive among the nation’s highest-paid people, or what the best restaurants are,” said Rita Tennkae, Associate Deputy Director of the Division of Corporation Finance. ”This is information that people can really use.”

The opportunity to obtain data in real time could also offer an advance alert to investors that it may be time to sell a company’s stock. ”For instance,” said Sue Offen, Assistant Deputy Director of the Enforcement Division, ”if you notice the CFO is making late-night infomercial purchases, that might signal insomnia -- which in turn could mean troublesome issues on the company’s radar that are keeping the execs awake nights.”

Before voting unanimously to publish the revised proposal for public comment, the Commission devoted over 400 hours to so-called executive session meetings to reconcile the differing views of Commissioners. In the end, the sheer length of the debate among Commissioners led to some reluctant acquiescence.

”Chairman Cox pushed what is obviously a priority for him through hours and hours and hours of exhausting discussion, and months and months of proposal and re-proposal,” said Commissioner Annette Nazareth. ”Frankly, I don’t understand the reasons for this, but I can no longer remember my original objections,” she added.

 

 

 

This Forum program is open, free of charge, to all shareholders of the invited corporate participants, and to any fiduciaries or professionals concerned with the investment decisions of those shareholders, according to the posted Conditions of Participation.  The Forum's purpose is to provide shareholders with access to information and a free exchange of views on issues relating to their investment interests described in the Forum Summary As stated in the Conditions, all Forum participants are expected to make independent use of information obtained through the Forum, subject to the privacy rights of other participants.  It is a Forum rule that participants will not be identified or quoted without their explicit permission.

This Forum program has been organized with the support of Hermes Equity Ownership Services, Ltd.  It is the first in an expected series that will be managed by a not-for-profit “Institute” to be established for the purpose of continuing the Forum programs conducted by Gary Lutin.

Inquiries and requests to be included in the Forum's distribution list may be addressed to op@shareholderforum.com.  The information provided to Forum participants is intended for their private reference, and permission has not been granted for the republishing of any copyrighted material.

All material on this web site is published by Gary Lutin, who is responsible for conducting the Forum.